On the Andertons YouTube channel they did a comparison video of two real Clon Centaur pedals with a limited edition Wampler Germanium Tumnus. They couldn’t hear or feel a difference…
I own a QC and a ‘Wampler Germanium Tumnus’. For the life of me I can’t hear a difference between the built-in ‘Myth Drive’ and the analog Clon clone…
To this day I’m still considering selling the tumnus because the sound and feel is identical. But maybe I’m going analog again!?
I don’t see how a capture will get you closer to the real thing. It will just be different. Whether that’s better for you is a matter of taste imo